Sugar Mamas Sugar Mamas

Order book · Pies & cheesecakes

Ten inches. Made to order.

Medium-depth pies and New York–style cheesecakes, baked for your date. Holiday preset orders post online in early November.

Turtle cheesecake with chocolate ganache, salted caramel and pecans in a graham crust, on a butcher block

01 · Pies · 10" medium depth

$35 each.

PiePrice
Apple$35
Triple Berry$35
Bourbon Pecan$35
Key Lime$35
Chocolate Cream$35
Pumpkin$35

02 · Cheesecakes · 10"

$75 each.

CheesecakePrice
Plain (NY Style)$75
Pumpkin$75
Fruit Coulis Topped$75
Sweet Sour Cream Topped$75
Turtle$75

03 · Thanksgiving

Blackout November 24–28.

The order calendar is blacked out November 24–28. Thanksgiving preset orders are handled online through the holiday store, posted in early November.

Want a pie before then? Pick a date on the calendar.

Check a date
Key lime pies piled with whipped cream and dried lime wheels

Pie for the table? Get it in the book.

Send the questionnaire, then Sugar Mamas calls you to take the order. Or skip straight to the phone.