Sugar Mamas928-221-8440

Pies & cheesecakes

Crust, cream
& the final detail.

Ten-inch pies and cheesecakes, made to pre-order. Choose the kind you’d like and confirm the date with Sugar Mamas.

Plan your pre-order 928-221-8440
Sugar Mamas Key Lime pies topped with lime slices
Sugar Mamas Key Lime pies topped with lime slices
Sugar Mamas Turtle cheesecake
Sugar Mamas Turtle cheesecake

10 inch

Cheesecakes, $75 each.

  • Plain (NY Style)$75
  • Pumpkin$75
  • Fruit Coulis Topped$75
  • Sweet Sour Cream Topped$75
  • Turtle$75
Turtle cheesecake in a jar
Turtle cheesecake in a jar — product photograph; the listed $75 price is for a ten-inch cheesecake.

10 inch · medium depth

Pies, $35 each.

  • Apple$35
  • Triple Berry$35
  • Bourbon Pecan$35
  • Key Lime$35
  • Chocolate Cream$35
  • Pumpkin$35
Sugar Mamas Key Lime pies topped with lime slices
Sugar Mamas Key Lime pies topped with lime slices

Prices published by Sugar Mamas, September 2026. Final pricing depends on your order; call to confirm.

Small batch · pre-order only

Bring your favourite.
We’ll talk cake.

Start with the questionnaire, then place your order by phone. Confirm your date and final details with Sugar Mamas.

Prepare your order

Open original photograph ↗